What To Do If The At Fault Insurance Company Won’t Pay Your Claim

What To Do If The At Fault Insurance Company Won’t Pay Your Claim

By: Agavni Tulekyan | May 23, 2025 |

Imagine you're involved in a car accident, sustaining injuries that need immediate medical attention. Then, shockingly, you discover the at fault insurance company won’t pay your medical expenses. This scenario is familiar to Los Angeles car accident lawyers, who often deal with disputes involving stubborn insurers. Don’t lose hope this guide will navigate you through the insurance dispute process and outline the essential steps to take when facing payment refusal.

Understanding Why an At Fault Insurance Company Won’t Pay

Knowing why an at fault insurance company won’t pay your medical bills is critical. Common reasons include disputes over fault, disagreements on compensation amounts, and policy limitations.

Insurance companies aim for profit, employing tactics like delaying claims, disputing liability, denying compensation, or referencing policy exclusions to refuse payments.

Disputing Fault with the At Fault Insurance Company

Insurance companies frequently dispute fault, arguing their client wasn't responsible or was only partially at fault. These claims cause significant delays in compensation, especially when insurers blame victims.

Having concrete evidence, such as police reports, witness testimonies, and documentation proving the other driver’s fault, is vital. Solid evidence helps counter insurance companies’ fault disputes, increasing your chances of a fair settlement.

Disagreements on Compensation with the At Fault Insurance Company

Another common refusal arises from compensation disputes. Insurers may consider the requested compensation excessive and propose lower amounts, prolonging settlement negotiations.

Knowing the value of your claim is crucial. Consulting with a personal injury lawyer ensures proper valuation of your claim, improving your negotiating position and helping you obtain rightful compensation.

Policy Limitations Causing Refusals

Sometimes, policy limitations prevent insurers from fully covering medical expenses, placing financial burdens on injured victims. Even loyal premium payers might find their policies insufficient.

Regularly reviewing your insurance policy helps avoid surprises. Understanding your coverage limits and exclusions ensures adequate protection when needed.

Steps to Take When the At Fault Insurance Company Won’t Pay

If you encounter payment refusal, proactive steps can help resolve the issue and secure the compensation you deserve.

Gather Evidence to Support Your Claim

Collecting substantial evidence is vital. Evidence should include police reports, medical records, witness statements, and accident scene photographs. A well-documented case challenges the insurer's refusal, enhancing your compensation prospects.

Maintain records of all interactions with the insurance company. Emails, letters, and call logs demonstrate your cooperation and diligence, strengthening your legal position if the dispute escalates.

Consult with a Car Accident Attorney

When an at fault insurance company won’t pay, consulting a car accident attorney is essential. Experienced lawyers provide invaluable advice, evaluate your case, and negotiate assertively with insurers.

Legal counsel signals seriousness to insurers, potentially avoiding prolonged disputes. Insurers often become more willing to settle fairly when facing the threat of litigation.

Negotiate with the Insurance Company

Effective negotiation is crucial in resolving payment disputes. With your attorney’s assistance, present compelling evidence and reasonable settlement proposals.

A robust negotiation strategy usually results in a fair resolution, enabling timely compensation and recovery.

Filing a Lawsuit When the At Fault Insurance Company Won’t Pay

If negotiations fail, filing a lawsuit might become necessary. Legal proceedings allow a judge or jury to determine appropriate compensation.

Preparing Your Case for Court

Building a strong court case involves compiling extensive documentation, such as medical bills, police reports, and witness statements. Your attorney organizes evidence and crafts persuasive arguments proving insurer obligations.

Experienced attorneys also handle legal procedures, court document preparation, and deadline management, ensuring a properly presented case.

Taking Your Case to Trial

When court proceedings begin, your attorney presents your evidence to a judge or jury, countering the insurance company's arguments. Lawyers advocate vigorously for your deserved compensation.

Although trials can be unpredictable, meticulous preparation and skilled legal guidance significantly boost your success odds.

Dealing with Uninsured or Underinsured Drivers

Handling uninsured or underinsured drivers complicates accident claims, as these drivers lack sufficient coverage for your medical expenses.

Importance of Uninsured Motorist Coverage

Adding uninsured motorist coverage to your policy provides critical protection against uninsured drivers. This optional coverage ensures medical expenses are covered if the at fault driver lacks adequate insurance.

Filing a Claim with Your Own Insurance Company

When an at fault driver is uninsured or underinsured, filing a claim with your insurer is necessary. Provide documentation and evidence demonstrating liability clearly. A personal injury attorney can streamline this complex process, maximizing your compensation chances.

Tips for Avoiding Disputes with the At Fault Insurance Company

Preventing disputes from arising initially is ideal. Periodic policy reviews and consistent communication with your insurer minimize dispute risks.

Review Your Insurance Policy Regularly

Regular policy reviews clarify your coverage, limitations, and exclusions. Proactive updates ensure adequate protection, reducing potential misunderstandings.

Remember, insurance policies are contracts between you and your insurer; clarity ensures smoother claims.

Maintain Good Communication with Your Insurer

Clear, timely communication fosters smooth claim processing. Provide necessary documentation promptly, maintain comprehensive communication records, and respond swiftly to inquiries.

Good communication reduces dispute likelihood, ensuring prompt issue resolution.

Tulekyan Law: Committed Personal Injury Attorneys

At Tulekyan Law, our expert attorneys advocate passionately for accident victims statewide.

Operating on a contingency fee basis means no upfront fees you pay only if we win. For dedicated, effective legal representation, contact Tulekyan Law today for a free consultation.

Reasons to Consider
Why Choose
Tulekyan Law 
Personal Injury 
Lawyer
Aggressive Advocacy
Proven Track Record
Unparalled Experience
Client-Centered Approach
Local Insight
No Fee Until We Win
Schedule A
Free Consultation
fill out the form

"*" indicates required fields

Full Name*
Required Fields *
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
chevron-down